| | Head Pastor | Associate Pastor | Deacon |
| | 
Rev. James McNamee
1946-1968 | | |
| | |
Rev. Joseph L. Carroll
1955-1961 | |
| | |
Rev. Henry E. Kelly
1967-1968 | |
| | 
Rev. John J. Sullivan
1968-1972 | | |
| | | 
Rev. Dennis C. Dorney
1968-1972 | |
| | | 
Rev. Thomas P. Biller
1968- | |
| | |
Rev. Paul W. Hight
1971-1973 | |
| | 
Rev. Msgr. Cecil E. Finn
1972-1988 | | |
| | | 
Rev. Patrick J. Gaalaas
1972-1976 | |
| | |
Rev. Jake A. Males
1976-1978 | |
| | |
Rev. Christopher P. Daigle
1978-1982 | |
| | | 
Rev. Leonard J. Higgins
1982-1983 | |
| | |
Rev. Timothy G. McLane
1983-1988 | |
| | 
Rev. Daniel A. Perlinski
1988-1996 | | |
| | 
Rev. Daniel H. Mueggenborg
1996-2001 | | |
| | | | 
Deacon John Steward
1985-2000 |
| | 
Rev. Jack A. Gleason
2001-2011 | | |
| | | 
Rev. Stuart Crevcoure
2001-2002 | |
| | | | 
Decon Robert DeWeese
1999- |